‘I Probably Would’ve Convicted’: Alternate Juror Breaks Silence About Cosby Trial

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — A man who says he was an alternate juror in the Bill Cosby sexual assault trial is having his say. He spoke Monday to WDVE, the radio station that broadcasts the Pittsburgh Steelers games.

As one of six alternates, Mike McCloskey was in the courtroom for the trial, but didn’t deliberate with the 12 jurors. Despite that, he remained sequestered in Montgomery County.

“Over a week of trial deliberations, I had to go through this,” he said, “and I literally couldn’t talk about it.”

COMPLETE COVERAGE: Bill Cosby Mistrial

McCloskey says he felt “ridiculously sick” when he found out the jury couldn’t reach a verdict.

“I probably would’ve convicted,” he said, “based on the evidence I heard.”

He says he’d expected the jurors to break their silence on the bus ride back to Pittsburgh.

“Nobody wanted to talk about it,” McCluskey said. “There was complete silence. It was craziest, eeriest bus ride I’ve ever taken.”

More from Molly Daly

More From CBS Philly

Small Hotel Getaway
Eclipse 2017
#CBS3Summerfest

Watch & Listen LIVE