Family Of Disabled Girl In Need Of Kidney Transplant Gets An Apology From CHOP

By Pat Loeb

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) – Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia has apologized to the parents of a severely disabled South Jersey toddler who sought a kidney transplant for their daughter there. The hospital initially denied the child a transplant, but officials now say no decision has been made.

The story of Amelia Rivera, a three-year-old Stratford girl with Wolf-Hirschorn syndrome, was an internet sensation and brought down an avalanche of criticism on Children’s Hospital last month after her mother wrote an emotional blog post about a meeting with a CHOP transplant doctor.

Chrissy Rivera reported that the doctor denied Amelia a transplant and gave the reason as “mental retardation.”

In a statement, CHOP’s chief medical officer says he “can unequivocally state that we do not disqualify transplant patients on the basis of intellectual ability,” and he blamed poor communication for the incident.

The statement goes on to say “evaluation for transplant is a long and involved process,” and no decision on Amelia’s case has been made.

It also quotes Amelia’s parents as praising CHOP for “updating their process and materials” and expressing hope that “this experience will heighten the medical community’s sensitivity to the disabilities community.”

Top Content On CBSPhilly

More from Pat Loeb

One Comment

  1. SISTER says:


  2. Lois68 says:

    I hope CHOP sticks to its guns. There is a limited amount of health care dollars, and they shouldn’t be allocated according to sobs the loudest or gets a stupid newsperson to report on it.

    1. rkyoung says:

      When your child isn’t good enough to live because somebody doesn’t think their life is valuable enough, you get back to us on that! Who do you think you are?

  3. Jonn says:

    When do they plan to implant this apology so it can begin filtering her blood?

  4. fredreed says:

    I was at chop when I was a baby and I am extremely apalled or more angry that they are still treating patients with garbage. This use to be the best children’s hospital around but in my opinion it’s not a very good hospital at least If you have a sick child on hand. If a child needs a kidney or whatever there should be no reason why there should be any delay to give it to them.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide To Iconic Carousels
Getaway Summer Slopes

Watch & Listen LIVE