Chester County Teens Sentenced In Feces-Filled Cake Prank

By Mark Abrams

WEST CHESTER, Pa. (CBS) — Three Chester County women who admitted to “contaminating” a birthday cake with human waste and then giving it to a classmate for her and her family to eat have been sentenced to some unusual community service time by a judge.

The three women — 19-year-old Mayra Flores, 18-year-old Ana Mirles, and 18-year-old Sandra Ortiz — all are from Avondale, Pa.

They pleaded guilty in Chester County court this week to making a birthday cake for a classmate and putting human feces in it. The victim, who took it home to family members to eat, later reported a bad smell and taste to the cake.

Those who ate it complained of stomach problems.

Authorities recovered the cake and conducted a lab analysis and found it contained E. coli bacteria, consistent with human waste.

Assistant District Attorney Carolyn DeLaurentis says when the three were sentenced, Judge William Mahon used some latitude in devising an appropriate punishment.

“They all have to do 200 hours of community service and the judge ordered that that community service be either cleaning toilets and urinals, cleaning bed pans or cleaning up dog poop at a park,” DeLaurentis said.

Top Content On CBSPhilly


One Comment

  1. Gra pe A pe Rules2 says:

    They’re pretty old to be students, but what can you expect from fecal-skinned sa vages?

  2. Valerie B. says:

    They are referring to them as three “women”? I’d beg to differ. Sounds like a bunch of immature brats to me.

  3. Jackie says:

    Yes, the Judge should have given them all 3 duties. AND he should have given them some of that same cake (had it not been disposed of) to eat. I cannot imagine what type of brains these grown women had (or don’t have) that they think it’s cool to give someone fecal material to eat. All fecal material contains enough bacteria to make anybody sick. Plus 90 days in jail would have been good too. E-coli????? 190 days jail time isn’t enough! Fun and games, this is NOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  4. Di says:

    I think the judge should have imposed ALL of the above , not “or”! Also,200 hours was not enough! Perhaps he should have also included cleaning in a mental institution…………… there is obviously something “wrong” with them mentally. An absolute disgrace !

  5. vanessa says:

    the judge should have made them eat that cake and still do community service .these were not minors they are 18 and older………….

    1. Gra pe A pe Rules2 says:

      Let them eat cake! THAT cake! LOL!

  6. Nena1216 says:

    I’m glad the judge gave them a taste of their own medicine. Hope they learned their lesson.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide To Iconic Carousels
Getaway Summer Slopes

Watch & Listen LIVE