Pa. School: Banned ‘Boobies’ Bracelets Are Vulgar

PHILADELPHIA (AP) — An eastern Pennsylvania school district sued over its ban on “I (heart) boobies!” bracelets calls the phrase “vulgar” and says it led a middle-school boy to touch a girl’s breast.

The Easton Area School District defended its ban on the breast-cancer awareness bracelets in a new court filing.

The American Civil Liberties Union sued the district last month on behalf of two girls suspended for wearing the popular bracelets. The ACLU considers it a free-speech case, but the school district strongly disagreed in papers filed Wednesday.

“The district did not suspend either student for the expression of her viewpoint. The district’s actions were calculated to teach students appropriate ways to express their viewpoints,” the filing said.

The two sides are due in federal court Dec. 16, when the ACLU will ask a judge to reverse both the ban and the in-school suspensions of plaintiffs Brianna Hawk, 13, and Kayla Martinez, 12. Both attend Easton Area Middle School.

Their suspensions came with a one-month ban on school activities, but U.S. District Judge Mary McLaughlin persuaded the school to let the girls attend a recent dance while the case plays out.

Schools from Florida to California have banned the $4 bracelets, which are sold by the nonprofit Keep A Breast Foundation of Carlsbad, Calif., to raise awareness and funds for breast cancer organizations.

Fans believe the irreverent message promotes discussions about breast cancer among young people.

Easton has said little publicly about their stance, but disclosed in court papers that the bracelets have caused distractions—and more.

“Middle school boys made sexual comments to middle school girls and there was a case of a boy touching a girl on the breast. All of these circumstances were disruptive to the classroom and each individual child’s education,” the school said.

The ACLU believes the school should focus on the inappropriate behavior, not the bracelets.

“They offer a couple of instances of, basically, boys behaving badly, but they don’t tell us that they punished the boys behaving badly. Instead they want to cut off speech,” lawyer Mary Catherine Roper said.

While school officials often argue they have the right to set their own limits on appropriate student speech, the U.S. Supreme Court has ruled otherwise, she said. The Supreme Court has allowed school bans on obscene, lewd and substantially disruptive speech, along with speech promoting illegal drug use.

“The right result is not that we can’t talk about anything that a 12-year-old boy might make an inappropriate remark about,” Roper said.

(© Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)


One Comment

  1. Mali says:

    There is a bracelet available that already promotes breast cancer awareness – and it is tastefully done. Not like the one these young girls are sporting…what’s wrong with their parents?????

  2. John Chroniger says:

    So if boys go around saying they also love boobies will that be considered ok speech?

  3. Nathan says:

    Ashely is naive if she believes that *middle school* boys will NOT make these bracelets about set. I am a substitute teacher and every time I have seen one of those bracelets in class, it was being used to tease, mock, or harass another student. Never have I seen it being used as awareness. It is a very effective tool for teenage boys to use to make fun of girls for how developed or undeveloped they are. Maybe they ACLU should spend a few days observing a middle school classroom before they decide to fight the school on this one.

  4. Ashely says:

    LOL REALLY bracelets are NOT what leads middle-school boys to touch a girl’s breast! Second of all, its about breast cancer awareness nothing about sex. People need to stop seeing sexual meanings behind everything.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide: Best Of The Jersey Cape Clams

Watch & Listen LIVE