By Todd Quinones

WINSLOW TOWNSHIP, N.J., (CBS)Police indicate five juvenile victims over the past 30 may have been sexually assaulted by a church organist, and there may be more victims.

READ MORE: PPA Adding Patrols To Monitor Illegally Parked Cars In Bike Lanes Amid Growing Number Of Bicyclists Killed In Philly

Winslow Township Police say 71-year-old Joseph Cuthbert was a volunteer organist here at the Erial Community Church in Gloucester Township.

Police say Cuthbert worked for years as an organist for several South Jersey churches and that is how he came into contact with his juvenile victims.

His neighbor and fellow parishioners say Cuthbert is a dedicated Christian who can recite bible passages.

“Very, very hard to believe. It’s mind boggling. It’s just unbelievable,” neighbor Barbara DeCicco said.

Winslow Township Police tell CBS 3 the initial alleged victim recently came forward claiming Cuthbert sexually assaulted him around September of last year.

READ MORE: Father Of 18-Year-Old Killed In Sand Collapse On Toms River Beach Shares Message Remembering Son

The subsequent investigation police say led to four other alleged victims dating back 30 years.

Police say the 71-year-old who was arrested at his Sicklerville home was also an organist for a time at Christ Community Church in Newfield.

“I thought it was a joke. I really did,” neighbor Joan Warner said.  “I still can’t believe it really.”

Joseph Cuthbert was charged with five counts of aggravated sexual assault, five counts criminal sexual contact and five counts endangering the welfare of a child. He was remanded to the Camden County Jail on $250,000 full cash bail.

Police are now asking that any additional victims or those who have information on the victims call the Winslow Twp. Criminal Investigations Division at 609-561-3300 ext. #1147.

MORE NEWS: Dirt Bike Rider Wanted In Hit-And-Run That Left Teenager Dead, Philadelphia Police Say