Promises To Identify Your Lineage, But It’s Not Exactly What You Get

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — For a $100, promises to find your ethnicity and maybe distant relatives, but you may not get exactly what you think you’re paying for.

“It gives you some clues, it gives you direction, some things to try out and look at, but it isn’t the final answer,” says Carol Sheaffer with the Genological Society of Pennsylvania.

“When you get the results, you get two major things,” she says. “The first is your ethnicity report, telling you where all your DNA came from all around the world, and the other are hits, and those are people who actually share some part of your DNA and to whom you are related.”

In other words: it’s not a guarantee.

As the company explains, the ethnicity report is based on common DNA profiles from one of Ancestry’s 26 different “regions,” but not necessarily a specific country.

“It’s very hard to pinpoint an exact place,” says Sheaffer. “People moved around, people lived in different countries, they became involved and married to people in those countries, and left the area but created descendants that had part of their DNA.”

For children who were adopted, and may have no family records, it’s even harder to find an exact heritage. For example, babies adopted from East Asia, she says:

“It’s a real mix, and it’s a pretty wide area they don’t specifically help you pin it down to a village.”

Scheaffer says that’s where the list of possible relatives come in.

“If you find someone in your list of matches that you can connect with, and you have a common ancestor you both know about, you can begin to go back in time to find a specific place.”

When you get the test, the information is stored in Ancestry’s DNA database, and if someone with a common genetic profile also gets tested, they will you an update about that person, or possible relative. says they base the results off other DNA profiles in the database, but cannot precisely narrow in on exact locations. They say they hope the technology will become more accurate as it develops.

Full Statement from

Tests that reveal someone’s genetic ethnicity do so by comparing a person’s DNA signature to those of test panels around the world to find similarities in the genetic code that can point to ethnic origins. One of the challenges genetic testing struggles with is the fact that there are fewer samples from some areas of the world which makes it more challenging to offer granular results. The scientific community is actively addressing this issue to improve the representation of all populations in scientific studies.

As more people take the DNA tests like ours, the science underlying the estimates of genetic ethnicity will evolve and results can become more refined.

More from Kristen Johanson

One Comment

  1. Great article! We built a face recognition app that lets you upload your photo below to see your ethnicity makeup. It takes seconds and can point you in the right direction without spending a single cent. Try it here, it’s free –>

  2. So, out of the thousands of populations in the world, they report 26 and they get a free coverage? that doesn’t sound very reliable people! some companies report hundreds of ancestries!

  3. Interesting article! Unfortunately, your experience is quite common. Many ancestry tests that have been around a long time “rest on their laurels” and rely on outdated algorithms instead of innovating. But you can’t wait for testing to improve: you have to do the research and make it happen! I work for DDC, one of the largest private DNA labs in the country. We offer an ancestry test called GPS Origins, which uses next-generation algorithms to get the most accurate results on the market today, and can even pinpoint the town or village for your ancestral origins. While the test doesn’t give you people matches, it gives you location matches,which will tell you a lot about your heritage and where to begin looking. The test analyzes 800,000 autosomal DNA markers, 36 gene pools, and 862 reference populations. It can pinpoint where your DNA began 1,000 or more years ago, and shows the migration route of your DNA from the past moving forward, on both the maternal and paternal sides. If anyone’s interested, visit our website:

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide To Iconic Carousels
Getaway Summer Slopes

Watch & Listen LIVE