NOW LIVE: Eyewitness News

Review: Sassafras Bar

Sassafras
135x90_FoodHunt Glen Macnow's Great Hamburger Hunt
Read More

By Glen Macnow

Score: 7.25
Price: $13.95 for a “John Dillinger” burger with caramelized onions and gruyere cheese.
Location: 48 S. Second Street, Old City

Lots of burger choices here: Sirloin, lamb, bison, ostrich, veggie. For purposes of this contest, we stuck with sirloin for one and bison for the second. But we’ll be back for the others. Correction: Make that all the others except veggie.

We were delighted to see that they know how to charbroil a burger at Sassafras. It had some good burn flavor on the outside, but was still juicy and pink on the inside. A hand-formed patty, lightly seasoned, topped with those sweet onions and bubbly gruyere cheese. One thing we’ve learned over the past 40 days is that gruyere is the most-underrated of cheeses. Perfect for a burger. Kicks American cheese’s ass.

Here’s what else we’ve learned: A genuinely well-prepared and seasoned burger doesn’t require ketchup. And this one didn’t. It takes a lot for me to put aside that Heinz jar, but at Sassafras, it stayed on the table. This is a solid Old City joint that’s been around for a while. Keep feeding me that burger, the unusually tasty sweet potato fries and another Dogfish Head 60 Minute IPA, and I’ll keep returning.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 34,906 other followers