NOW LIVE: Eyewitness News

Prosecutors Of Philadelphia Priests Raise Decades Of Buried Abuse Cases

By Tony Hanson

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — The prosecution in the Philadelphia clergy sex abuse case has alleged a history of coverup and enabling by the Archdiocese of Philadelphia (see related stories).

Today, as they built their case against Msgr. William Lynn and another priest, prosecutors presented evidence of similar actions by the archdiocese going back decades.

In one case dating back to the 1960s, prosecutors say, an alleged serial pedophile priest was allowed to remain in ministry for two decades after admitting his crimes.

Prosecution evidence alleges that Fr. Raymond Leneweaver repeatedly admitted to the archdiocese that he was having sex with boys at various times from the late ’60s to the late ’70s.

There was treatment at an archdiocesan hospital, the evidence shows.  His prognosis was always favorable, and he was returned to ministry each time.

In 1980, Father Leneweaver was assigned to Bucks County because, according to a church official, it was one of the few remaining areas where his scandalous actions were not known.

Leneweaver remained in ministry until the early ’80s, when he quit the priesthood.  He later wanted back in, but defendant William Lynn and other church officials recommended against it.

The defense, through questioning, suggested this demonstrates that Msgr. Lynn was doing his job, trying to keep pedophiles away from children.

Another victim who came forward with her story of abuse also testified today.

She said that she came from a devout Catholic family and her mother went to mass at least once a day, volunteering her daughter to work in the rectory.

That’s where, she says, she was fondled repeatedly by Father Albert Kostelnick for about three years.

She says she later learned that two younger sisters had also been molested but says she didn’t report it then because she didn’t think her mother would believe her.

When she told her mother years later, the woman testifield today, the response she got was, “Let it go.”

She finally came forward in 2001, and  the prosecution alleges that despite multiple other reports about Fr. Kostelnick going back decades, the Archdiocese of Philadelphia allowed him to remain in ministry.

Kostelnick denied the abuse allegation but was later removed from ministry.

Lynn, who oversaw the assignment of priests to schools and parishes across the Philadelphia region, faces accusations that he failed to keep priests accused of sexual abuse away from minors.   Co-defendant Rev. James Brennan is accused of sexually abusing boys in the 1990s.

Top Content On CBSPhilly



More from Tony Hanson

One Comment

  1. Street Justice says:

    Father Kostelnick was a long time priest in residence at St. John of the Cross parish in Roslyn, PA. I used to serve as an altar boy to him from time to time back in the day when I was in grade school at St. John’s. Once he slapped me in the back of the head on the Altar for not hitting my marks on time during the mass i.e. ringing the bell, bringing up the wine/water etc.. I guess I was lucky he only tried that. I only hope he gets what he deserves and that would be “Roslyn” street justice.

  2. Mother Hen says:

    Of course Jeannie. True men of God would never allowed this. They are great deceivers.
    My guess is centuries…not decades thoug

  3. These revelations of coverups, running back decades only underlines how superfluous Monsignors, bishops, archbishops and a cardinal are to the running of an Archdiocese. They are just in place “to keep up appearances,” and to ensure their parishioners that “Men of God,” are running the Church, when they are nothing more than Vatican puppets! Real men, as well as “Real Men of God, wouldn’t have allowed the tragedy of repeated molestation, rape and sodomy to occur. Everyone responsible for the coverup should be brought to trial, and if convicted, made to fulfill a court imposed sentence! Everyone, from the top on down.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide To Iconic Carousels
Getaway Summer Slopes

Watch & Listen LIVE