Nutter Unveils New Budget Plan; Possible Sticker Shock For Homeowners

By Mike Dunn

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — Saying the City of Philadelphia needs a fair and honest property tax system, Mayor Nutter today announced plans to move ahead with a new property assessment system that will bring in an extra $90 million.

The announcement came today as the mayor delivered his new budget to City Council.  He told Council members that the current assessment system must go:

“For decades this broken, mysterious system has meant that many people have been paying more than they should, while others have paid less than they should,” the mayor told councilmembers.

So, starting in the coming year, property taxes will be based on a brand-new set of assessments that are part of a move to a system called the “Actual Value Initiative,” or AVI.

“Some Philadelphians will see their tax bills cut by this reform,” said Nutter. “Others, whose homes have been undervalued for years, will probably have to pay more.”

The tax rate, or millage, will be lowered, but it won’t be revenue-neutral.  Instead, property taxes as a whole next year will bring in at least $90 million, all of which will go to the deficit-ridden school district.

Listen to Mayor Nutter’s full budget address in this CBS Philly podcast…

Download podcast for later listening

The portion of property taxes that goes to the city will remain level with this year.

Nutter says they hope to have buffers in place to minimize the hit.

“We have asked the General Assembly in Harrisburg to authorize homestead relief for Philadelphia, something that is already available to other jurisdictions in Pennsylvania.  We will also work with City Council to put in place smoothing measures to phase in these new values over time, to minimize any impact felt by property owners.  And many low-income senior citizens will be eligible for the tax freeze program so that they will see no increases in their real estate bills,” he said.

Nutter acknowledged that the change will be a tough sell:

“This isn’t the easiest, most popular reform that we could have taken on.  If it was, somebody would have done it by now.  But we must have a fair system, an honest system, a transparent system, and so we’re going to take it on.”

There will be no new taxes or formal tax increases in the mayor’s budget.  Nutter said that in the following fiscal year, beginning July 2013, he will restart wage tax reductions that had been suspended during the height of the recession.

Critics — including some on City Council — were already described the mayor’s property tax plan as a “back-door tax hike.”  City finance director Dubow, prior to the mayor’s speech, rejected that characterization, saying the extra $90 million merely reflects an increase in property values since the last full reassessment eight years ago.

“It’s the same thing as if wages go up,” Dubow told KYW Newsradio.  “Values of homes have gone up, we are capturing that increase.”

City Council must approve the change, and it may be a tough sell.  Budget hearings begin next week.

Beyond property taxes, the mayor’s proposed budget is slightly larger than the current one: $3.6 billion compared to $3.5 billion.  The plan projects modest growth in other revenues, including wage and sales tax revenues.

The mayor’s proposed budget also:

  • sets aside $4 million to hire 400 new police officers.
  • reduces the amount of overtime allocated to the Philadelphia Fire Department by about $2 million.  Officials say this is possible because the department will, for the first time in several years, begin hiring new firefighters.  Between 80 and 160 new firefighters are expected in the first “class.”  Officials say the department’s controversial police of “rolling brownouts” (temporary closures of fire stations to reduce overtime) will continue despite the new hiring.
  • sets aside $9 million for design work to build a new Police Administration Building, at 46th and Market Streets in West Philadelphia.  The current PAB in center city (the “Roundhouse,” at 7th and Race) would be closed in three years when construction of the new facility is complete.  The new site would also include the city morgue and Health Department.
  • includes $20 million in capital funds for a full-scale renovation of JFK Plaza, better known as “Love Park.”  The project will complement the ongoing renovation of nearby Dilworth Plaza, the west apron of City Hall.
  • adds $4.5 million in capital funds for renovations to branch libraries over three years.
  • adds $18 million in capital funds for street repaving.

Nutter also announced a partnership with Children’s Hospital to build a new health center in South Philadelphia.  And he said the city will build a new traffic operations center to better adjust signals and monitor traffic flow.

Top Content On CBSPhilly


More from Mike Dunn
  • Philadelphia Councilmembers Accept Need For Property Tax Overhaul, With Some … | PropertyPlace

    […] a mayor’s bill debate this morning (see associated story), Councilman Curtis Jones says he and his colleagues will have to work together for what he calls […]

  • Philadelphia Councilmembers Accept Need For Property Tax Overhaul, With Some … - Property For Rent :: Property For Rent

    […] the mayor’s budget speech this morning (see related story), Councilman Curtis Jones says he and his colleagues will have to work together for what he calls […]

  • Philadelphia Councilmembers Accept Need, Generally, For Property Tax Overhaul « CBS Philly

    […] the mayor’s budget speech this morning (see related story), Councilman Curtis Jones says he and his colleagues will have to work together for what he calls […]

  • Alan

    When Nutter’s plan involves resigning and firing the police chief I’ll listen.

  • MS

    Stop wasting the money!!! Clean your own house (City hall) before you push me out of Philadelphia. The city takes in plenty of money and waste so much more. Way to push people out of the city.

  • New and out soon

    Only having lived here a few years, I’m slowly starting to think my stay here will be short. Liberalism needs to be put to rest

  • amg

    Why do we still have 10 year tax abatements for home buyers who can afford to buy 3 to 5 hundred thousand dollar homes? If these people were paying property taxes like everyone else, we wouldn’t have to worry about the schools. Do away with the tax abatement and leave the middle class alone!

  • Philadelphia City Workers Express Anger Over Mayor’s Budget Priorities « CBS Philly

    […] the mayor’s budget address this morning (see related story), AFSCME District Council 33 president Pete Matthews held a rally near City Hall, saying his union […]

  • MikeInPhilly

    I would like to comment on the Finance Directors statement that an increase in real estate is the same as if your wages were increased. I disagree with his comparison in that if my wages increase that means I have more available cash. My home does not write me a check every month.
    Also, as usual with real estate the better you keep up your home (with your after tax dollars) the city wants to tax you again – talk about double taxation. Maybe the idea is to keep you neighborhood like a pig sty like other city places and you will benefit from lower taxes!!!!

  • Cynthia Petillo

    Just received our Township tax bill. Wow, looks like they’re nickel and diming us. So many new fees that are being slipped in with our property taxes. Many services I don’t use. What can we do? Not much, I suppose, but pay up. Joan Orlando makes a very salient point.

  • kelly

    Why don’t they drop the 10 year tax abatement, and make the new home buyers pay taxes like all the rest of us? I was a new home owner 15 years ago and got no breaks. Why are they getting them now? If you can afford to buy a home then you can pay your taxes too just like everyone else! If families can budget their incomes why can’t educated politicans budget the city’s money. Stop hiring crooks!

  • lord of war

    now we pay for the city school failure and for the buy out of the head of schools,

  • Joan Orlando

    Why is it that the middle class always has to pay to help Phila in their debt. Why don’t you look in other areas. DROP PROGRAM,WELFARE. II am a one income family who raised three children and never asked for help from our cityI. I am tired of supporting this city and hope i am able to move out of this city soon. The only thing I asked from the city is to have a tree removed which has my cement lifted 6 inc but was put on a waiting list. Tax payers should be first on the list. I am one of many that have the same feelings. What we need to is clean of City Hall..

  • Cleanup Philly

    When is Nutter going to collect the nearly half a billion in overdue property taxes? What county in PA or any state has a $465 million property tax debt in a stable real estate market? Only Philly:

  • Nutter anticipates $94M more in taxes for school district – Philadelphia Inquirer |

    […] CBS Local […]

blog comments powered by Disqus
Taz Goes Big!
Download Now!

Listen Live