3-On Your Side: Walking Away From A Mortgage

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — A new real estate report finds that 28 percent of homeowners in the United States are “underwater” on their mortgages. That means that they owe more on their homes than they are currently worth. As 3-On Your Side Consumer Reporter Jim Donovan finds, many homeowners are now torn between paying on a bad investment or just giving up and walking away.

Married with a toddler and a baby on the way, Jakob and Amilia Blackwell are feeling the pressure of living in an underwater home. Amilia says, “I don’t know what we’re going to do at all. I don’t have a clue.” Owing $40,000 more than their home is worth, they’re facing the moral versus business decision of making the payments or defaulting on their loan and walk away. Jakob says, “That’s our main conversation, what are we going to do.”

Money guru Suze Orman says, “If you are thinking about walking away from your house, doing a foreclosure or doing a shortsale, now is the time to do it.” In fact Orman says everyone should be looking at the value of their homes.

A homeowner owing $200,000 on a house that’s now worth only $100,000 is underwater by 50 percent. Orman says, “If you own a home that is 50 percent underwater, 70 percent underwater, it will never ever ever ever come back to where you purchased it.”

Orman says if you’re only 10 or 20 percent underwater, keep making your payments and ride out the housing crisis. But if it’s worse than that? She says, “Do the calculations everybody. How much is it costing you to actually stay in that house? How many years will it take for you to pay more than that house is worth? If it’s 3-years, 4-years, 5-years, are you kidding me, that’s a house you really need to say bye bye.

Watch the video…

Say your house is worth $150,000 and your monthly mortgage, including property tax and insurance is $2500. You will pay $150,000, the current value of your house in five years.In that case Orman says try to get your bank to modify your loan, lowering your monthly payments. If your bank won’t work with you, see if they’ll agree to a short sale, where they accept less money than you owe on your loan. If they won’t agree to that, try a deed in lieu of foreclosure. That is where you sign over the rights to the house, sparing the bank the costs of foreclosing on you. But Orman says, “If they won’t do that, then walk away.”

Orman says if you fail to get your bank to listen, you shouldn’t feel guilty. She says, “You have to make the attempt to work with them, then if they won’t work with you, then I think you can stand in your truth and leave that home”

Walking away from a mortgage isn’t something to be taken lightly. It not only will wreck your credit for years, it also can affect your neighbors by bringing down their property values. So if you’re considering this as an option, check with a credit counselor or tax accountant so you fully understand the consequences.

Reported by Jim Donovan, CBS 3

Top Content On CBSPhilly

More from Jim Donovan

One Comment

  1. caps says:

    So because YOU bought a big house and made a mistake you want to put the blame on the banks and we should stop paying. Thats no different then saying my 401K lost money so the government should add money to boost my loss. I say NO if you bought the house thats your problem. No one forced you to over buy !

  2. Kelli Karlton says:

    We are in the middle of a mortgage modification – we have been at it for 6 mos. My husband worked for a new homes builder for 20 years and was laid off and we are working once again, but fighting tooth and nail to keep our house. Walking away from our house – not an option for us!

  3. howard bateman says:

    I am really disapointed with the story on walking away from a mortgage. Orman’s position is almost encouraging defaulting on a promise to pay back money borrowed. While I understand desperate situations warrant desperate measures, the story implies that if the numbers don’t add up (anymore) you shouldn’t feel guilty about leaving your debt behind. It is morally wrong ! We all end up paying for such attitudes somewhere along the line – just like insurance fraud, white collar crime and shop lifting, it costs everyone. Bad message sent.

    1. john says:

      Amen Howard. God Forbid we go get second jobs, drop our premium cable bills, part with our iphones, or trade in our SUVs for a practical car. I am 34 years old and i was brought up to live within my means. There used to be a fear of defaulting on payments, not anymore.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide: Best Of The Jersey Cape Clams

Watch & Listen LIVE