3 On Your Side: Best Area Supermarkets

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) — If you’re like most people, you probably do the majority of your grocery shopping at one supermarket. But is that really the best store for you? In its latest survey of super markets, Delaware Valley Consumers’ CHECKBOOK compares price and quality. 3 On Your Side Consumer Reporter Jim Donovan shares which supermarkets came out on top.

Non-profit Consumers’ CHECKBOOK did secret shopping trips to compare the prices at one store versus another, and they also surveyed customers. Here is what they found out:

“When Checkbook.org does price comparisons, we use a market basket of 150 items, and go from store to store looking for the exact same items, name brand groceries and things like that, but also fresh produce and meats and so-on,” says Robert Krughoff, President of Delaware Valley Consumers’ CHECKBOOK.

When it comes to price, CHECKBOOK found Wal-Mart super centers were hard to beat. Krughoff says, “Wal-Mart looked very good on price, in fact their prices were about 20 percent lower than the prices at Acme, which is the biggest chain in the area.”

For the same shopping cart of products that would cost $86 at Wal-Mart, a customer would pay $91 at Giant, $95 at ShopRite, $96 at Wegman’s, $101 at Genuardi’s, $102 at Pathmark, $107 at Superfresh, $107 at Acme and $136 at Whole Foods.

When it comes to quality, Krughoff says, “We asked ordinary customers what they think of the quality of those stores, quality of the produce, quality of meats, and the overall service they got from those stores, pleasantness of staff, you know, even how hard it is to park.”

Wegman’s took the top spot and was rated superior by 86 percent of customers. While Wal-Mart scored high on price, only 25% percent of its customers gave it superior rating for quality.

CHECKBOOK found that the average family that spends about $150 a week on groceries could save as much as $1500 a year by switching to one of the area’s lower priced supermarkets.

Watch this video…

For more information about CHECKBOOKS’ supermarket survey, CLICK HERE.

Reported by Jim Donovan, CBS 3

More from 3 On Your Side

One Comment

  1. kate says:

    i shop at giant- decent everyday prices, good specials, clean environment and helpful staff
    would not shop at wal-mart — i know you can save but i cannot stand the low class customers maybe it is the area but i only went in once felt like everything was picked over, and overall store was dirty.

  2. Guess Who says:

    Acme is known for high prices.

    I’d shop at WalMart, but it’s dirty and infested with nasty, obnoxious Bantus.

  3. Susan says:

    I will never shop at a Wal-mart! Dirty and poor quality..don’t know what you’re getting! Why wasn’t Target priced??? I buy most of my groceries there, what I don’t find there I shop Acme (only things on sale though)! It pays to shop around..although with the price of gas you don’t want to travel too far! How about helping us with that issue Jim??

  4. meme says:

    Wal-Mart, Giant, Wegman are non-union. Acme, Pathmark, Super Fresh are union.

    1. adrian says:

      Union stores = outrageous prices and poor service.

  5. Friendly Fred says:

    Good job! Our experi9ence is that WalMart has great prices IF THEY HAVE THE PRODUCT. Their problem is the inconsistency of product availability. Our choice is Giant for overall shopping. The pricing is good, product availability without questions, and friendly folks.

  6. Ann B. says:

    Thank you, Jim Donovan, great info. I will incorporate into my shopping plans.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide: Best Of The Jersey Cape Clams

Watch & Listen LIVE