NOW LIVE: Eyewitness News

Criminal Prosecutor Hired By Church Speaks Out About Sex Abuse Case

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) – For nearly two decades, Gina Maisto Smith prosecuted cases of childhood sexual abuse in the Philadelphia District Attorney’s office.

She is a mother of five. She is also a Catholic, and for the next few months at least, Smith will be investigating possible cases of sexual abuse in her own church.

Cardinal Justin Rigali hired her this week after a Philadelphia Grand Jury found the Church might be turning a blind eye to such cases, despite convincing evidence.

That Grand Jury indicted three priests, a monsignor, and a former Catholic school teacher last week after investigating a new round of abuse allegations. However, the most disturbing finding of the Grand Jury’s report was that the Archdiocesan review board may have been ignoring evidence of sexual abuse, including lie detector tests, to acquit priests.

The Cardinal has asked Smith to reopen 37 cases, including three highlighted by the Grand Jury. The three priests involved in those cases – Father Joseph DiGregorio from Stella Maris in South Philadelphia, Father Stephen Perzan from St. Helena’s in East Oak Lane and retired Father Joseph Gallagher – have been suspended by the Cardinal pending Smith’s investigation.

“I can think of nothing more that I should be doing right now,” said Smith.

She is currently a partner at the Center City law firm Ballard Spahr, having left the District Attorney’s office in 2006. “I am a person that’s made up of many experiences, and [the allegations are] disturbing across the board to any person, not necessarily a Catholic.”

Despite her connection to the Church, she believes she can objectively investigate the cases of possible abuse.

“What’s right is right,” she said. “There are no lines to be drawn. I will not turn my back on child sexual abuse or allegations of a cover-up.”

Members of the Survivors Networks of those Abused by Priests, or SNAP, said this is still an “underwhelming” move by the Archdiocese of Philadelphia. Some called on the Cardinal to suspend all 37 priests in the cases involved.

Bishop Daniel Thomas of the Archdiocese said he hopes bringing in a former criminal prosecutor demonstrates “the seriousness with which the Archdiocese takes this.” Thomas said it’s important to remember that the recent Grand Jury report was the result of the Archdiocese alerting the District Attorney to possible cases of abuse.

To this point, the Archdiocese’s board that reviews allegations of sexual abuse has been made up of seven members, but several of them (at least three by the count of Eyewitness News) work full-time for the Archdiocese. Eyewitness News asked Bishop Thomas if that is a conflict of interest.

“Well, the Archdiocesan review board includes a varied different number of people,” he said. “They include some lay people, at least one pastor and some non-Catholics.”
The Archdiocese declined to reveal how much it is paying Smith. She says she does not know how long her investigation will take.

Watch the video…

Reported by Ben Simmoneau, CBS 3

Top Content On CBSPhilly


One Comment

  1. Steve Mizera says:

    I was a victim of molestation by layman Whelan at the St. Josephs House for Homeless and Induistrious Boys at 16th and Alleggheny Avs in 1953 and 1954.

    Was not the only one. My autobiography describes one incident and can be read at

    I have since heard from others who were also molested.
    How do I get in touch with Gina Smith?
    I checked the DAs web page but not email contact.

    And thanks for your pledge not to leave any stonue unturned to uncover cover-ups. I will be glad to help.

  2. John Shuster says:

    This is a standard Roman Catholic Church strategy. Appoint a apparently third-party indivivual to deal with a problem who exudes wholesomeness and justice. The goal is to placate the Catholic population in the Philadelphia area with the false hope that Smith will fix everything. A simple Internet search will reveal that Smith is a long-time church insider who has been working behind the scenes for years to contain survivors and protect their predators and sponsors. Smith will provide the good image to the people while doing exactly what the pope and Rigali want her to do. All the priests with credible accusations of abuse who are still in parishes will stay where they are because archdiocesan cash flow is more important than the safety of our children.

  3. Judy Block-Jones says:

    Is Justin Rigali trying to convince catholics, parishioners, victims, and district attorneys that this is a good step forward?

    The Grand Jury Report has already deemed these 37 credibly accused priests should not be working in this diocese with kids.

    They should be turned over to the law enforcement for further investigating..
    Church officials and who they hire are not the ones to be investigating crimes against kids.

  4. grumpy says:

    Eliminate the statute of limitations when it involves children and go after EVERYONE involved. A criminal is a criminal no matter how long ago the act was done.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

Getaway Guide To Iconic Carousels
Getaway Summer Slopes

Watch & Listen LIVE