NOW LIVE: Eyewitness News

Vick: Can We Separate The Player From The Person?

By Joseph Santoliquito

It’s easy to sit here tapping away on a keyboard playing desktop psychologist in trying to separate Michael Vick the player from Michael Vick the man. This week it’s become a favorite pastime of the media and the ravenous fans who follow the Eagles. In reality, when you peel to the core of that debate, it becomes much tougher. Vick certainly has a polarizing quality. Many, many people I know personally who have been life-long Eagles’ fans can’t bring themselves to look at the Eagles the same way again–openly cheering against them because of Vick.

I can understand their point. There’s no excusing what Vick did and it’s something he’ll have to live with for the rest of his life–if he has any kind of conscience.

Vick’s past, I believe, is a leading reason why many can’t view Vick as the starting quarterback logically, their judgment clouded by prejudice. But how could you not be absorbed and riveted by everything Vick did on Sunday, and the possibility of the Eagles being a much different team with him running the show? Repugnant as he is to some, a godsend he’s now become to others.

I’m guilty as charged. Count me among the many who would like to separate Vick the player from Vick the person (if it’s possible). Count me among the many who thinks Vick should be this team’s starting quarterback. Vick was mesmerizing against the Packers, a team that came away pleased Andy Reid didn’t wise up sooner and replace the woeful Kevin Kolb with Vick in the first half on Sunday. No one is asking me to sit down to a candlelight dinner with Vick. No one is asking me to let Vick take Spot for a walk in the park. He’s been asked to step in while Kolb recovers, and in my opinion, should have every chance to start.

There was a time when it was hard even looking at the man. He represented a morose view of the world, with all its naked scabs and barbs. But there are many who believe people can change their ways, they can see things they weren’t able to grasp before. I’d like to believe Micheal Vick is one of them. I’d like to believe Vick’s genuinely appreciative to Reid and the Eagles for giving him this chance to resurrect his career. Do I still harbor doubts whether or not Vick is truly reformed, sure, it’s only natural.

But again, he’s being asked to quarterback an NFL team, not head a childcare center.

The debate will continue to rage on. Vick has his supporters, many in the media think the Eagles should stick with Kolb and what is not only a fragile head but fragile ego, and still some of the buying public will refuse to watch the Eagles again until Vick is s dot in the team’s rearview mirror. It’s their prerogative, as it is others who are willing to separate the player from the person.


One Comment

  1. joseph santoliquito says:

    Thank you Art.


  2. Rick says:

    Great column. For me personally, I think it only makes sense to root for a person who you believe has good intentions, as opposed to rooting for a bad apple just because he happens to play on your favorite team. I’m definitely one who has a hard time separating what Vick did and the football player he is now. In the end though, I feel Vick is truly sorry for the sins he committed in the past, and I would like to see him fulfill the promises he made…I think the hardest part is having to listen to the rants of a lot of Vick supporters who just write off what he did as far as killing and torturing dogs (along w/ some other questionable behavior). It makes Vick almost a symbol of what’s wrong in society, and that’s not fair to Vick, because he now knows exactly how wrong he was…With all that said, I’ll stick to my guns and say you got to stick w/ Kolb and see what he has. Despite last Sundays horrendous performance, Kolb has showed promise and the potential to become a great QB for the Eagles, and I’ll argue that point w/ ANYONE including G-Cobb.

    1. joseph santoliquito says:

      Thanks Rick.


Comments are closed.

More From CBS Philly

2017 Guide To Philadelphia's Center City Sips

Watch & Listen LIVE